ATG Article of the Week: 2019 Was Big for Academic Publishing. Here’s Our Year in Review (The Scientist)

by | Dec 30, 2019 | 0 comments

In this post freelance journalist Diane Kwon takes note of a number of developments including how “the global push to make the scholarly literature open access continued in 2019. Some publishers and libraries forged new licensing deals, while in other cases contract negotiations came to halt, and a radical open access plan made some adjustments. Here are some of the most notable developments in the publishing world in 2019:

Perils of existing tools and practices

This year, The Scientist heard scientists’ complaints about the supplementary files that accompany journal articles and concerns about predatory journals on PubMed, the massive repository of abstracts and citations belonging to the US National Library of Medicine (NLM).

The NLM has quality control procedures for PubMed in place, but some articles have slipped through the cracks. Academics began raising concerns about the presence of predatory journals on PubMed for several years—and those worries remain today.

Supplementary files, on the other hand, have been criticized by scientists for containing broken hyperlinks and being published in clunky and outdated formats. As a result, more scientists are opting to deposit their files into online repositories hosted by universities, research institutions, and companies. Publishers, too, have begun to encourage this practice.

New tools can have their own flaws. This summer, several scientists noted that their papers were erroneously flagged by journals’ automatic plagiarism detectors. Instead of identifying actual cases of plagiarism, they were picking out author lists, methods, or references. Despite some of the current limitations of this technology, some publishers are working on extending the reach of artificial intelligence into other parts of the peer-review process, such as identifying statistical issues. “These will turn out to be useful editorial tools,” Bernd Pulverer, chief editor of The EMBO Journal, told The Scientist in June. “But [they] most certainly should not replace an informed expert editorial assessment, let alone expert peer review.”

UC breaks with Elsevier

At the end of February, contract negotiations between Elsevier and the University of California (UC) came to a halt. The two sides had failed to agree on terms after more than half a year of discussions. The previous contract ended in December 2018, but Elsevier continued to provide free access until July. Since then, UC has been unable to read new content published in Elsevier’s journals.

If you are interested in reading the entire article, please click here.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

LATEST NEWS

ATG Conferences, Meetings and Webinars 10/26/20

ATG Conferences, Meetings and Webinars 10/26/20 NISO Plus 2021 Call For Session Proposals! You probably know by now that NISO Plus 2021 will be a global, virtual-first event. What you may not know is that, unlike the inaugural conference in February 2020, next...

ATG Conferences, Meetings and Webinars 10/26/20

ATG Conferences, Meetings and Webinars 10/26/20 NISO Plus 2021 Call For Session Proposals! You probably know by now that NISO Plus 2021 will be a global, virtual-first event. What you may not know is that, unlike the inaugural conference in February 2020, next...

ATG News You Need to Start the Week: 10/26/20

ATG News You Need to Start the Week: 10/26/20 Expanded access to JSTOR and Artstor extended through June 2021 According to Library Technology Guides "As the COVID-19 crisis continues to disrupt higher education, ITHAKA is extending the JSTOR and Artstor expanded...

ATG News & Announcements 10/23/20

- ATG News & Announcements 10/23/20 - Initiative for Open Abstracts According to this announcement the Initiative for Open Abstracts "is a collaboration between scholarly publishers, infrastructure organizations, librarians, researchers and other interested...

ATG Conferences, Meetings, & Webinars 10/22/20

Don’t Forget! Apply for ACRL 2021 Virtual Conference Scholarships by October 23 The deadline to apply for a scholarship to attend the ACRL 2021 Virtual Conference is coming up this Friday, October 23.  REGISTER The ACRL 2021 Scholarship program provides...

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR PODCAST

Share This